What to Expect
A clear, efficient path from dispute to resolution — guided by a mediator with the experience to move the process forward.
Designed for Efficiency. Built on Experience.
Judge Batten's mediation process is structured to make the best use of everyone's time. Submissions are read carefully before the session. The day is organized to allow for both joint discussion and private caucus. And the process is guided throughout by a mediator who understands, from decades on the bench, exactly what it takes to move a matter toward resolution.
Initial Inquiry & Scheduling
Contact the office by phone or through the inquiry form to discuss your matter. Judge Batten's staff will confirm that the matter falls within his practice areas, check availability, and provide scheduling options. Most matters can be scheduled within two to four weeks of initial contact.
Both parties or their counsel must agree to mediation before a session is scheduled. If you are reaching out on behalf of one party, the office can assist in facilitating agreement with opposing counsel.
Mediation Agreement
Prior to the session, all parties execute a standard mediation agreement confirming the voluntary and confidential nature of the process, the mediator's role as a neutral, and the terms governing any settlement reached.
The agreement is provided in advance and is straightforward. Questions about its terms can be directed to the office before the session date.
Pre-Mediation Submissions
Each party submits a confidential mediation statement to Judge Batten at least five business days before the session. Submissions should include a concise statement of the facts, the key legal and factual issues in dispute, the party's assessment of damages or relief sought, and any prior settlement discussions.
Submissions are confidential and are not shared with the opposing party unless the submitting party expressly requests otherwise. Judge Batten reads every submission carefully before the session.
The Mediation Session
Sessions are typically held at a neutral location in the Cape May or Atlantic City area, or by videoconference when agreed by the parties. The session begins with a joint opening in which Judge Batten outlines the process and each party has an opportunity to make a brief statement. The balance of the session is conducted in private caucus, with Judge Batten meeting separately with each side.
Sessions are scheduled for a full day. Judge Batten does not impose artificial time pressure, but he is direct and substantive in his engagement with each party's position. Parties should come prepared to negotiate in good faith.
Caucus & Negotiation
The private caucus is the core of Judge Batten's process. In caucus, he engages candidly with each party about the strengths and weaknesses of their position, the realistic range of outcomes at trial, and the practical considerations that bear on settlement. He does not pressure parties toward any particular outcome — but he is willing to share his assessment when doing so will advance the process.
Parties are encouraged to have decision-makers present or available by phone throughout the session. Insurance carriers should have a representative with full settlement authority in attendance.
Resolution & Agreement
When the parties reach agreement, the terms are memorialized in a written settlement agreement executed before the session concludes. Judge Batten will assist in ensuring that the agreement is clear, complete, and enforceable.
If the matter does not resolve on the day of mediation, Judge Batten remains available for follow-up calls and, where appropriate, a second session. Many matters that do not resolve on the day settle within the weeks that follow.
Session Formats
In-Person & Remote
In-Person Mediation
Sessions are held at a neutral conference facility in the Cape May or Atlantic City area. The office will coordinate logistics and confirm the location in advance.
Videoconference Mediation
Remote sessions are available via Zoom or a platform of the parties' choosing. Videoconference mediation is fully effective for most matters and is particularly convenient for parties or counsel located outside southern New Jersey.
Arbitration
Judge Batten also serves as a qualified arbitrator for matters where the parties prefer a binding determination. Arbitration procedures are established by agreement of the parties and confirmed in a separate arbitration agreement.
Common Questions
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does a mediation session typically last?
Who should attend the mediation?
Is mediation confidential?
What is Judge Batten's fee?
What if the case doesn't settle on the day of mediation?
Ready to schedule a session?
Contact the office to discuss your matter and confirm availability. Most sessions can be scheduled within two to four weeks.